Brother-in-Law Reverend Robert Bolton brought his ministry to the Henley Chapel in 1824. The congregation increased and side galleries were added to the 1719 building in 1826. In February 1829, the foundation stone of an addition was laid, and later two rooms were added to the manse. Jay's father preached at the Chapel reopening in June 1829. It is speculated that the Chapel building activities were conducted by Jay.